Part 11 – last Article blog

11. Lender issues: Landlords will frequently reject tenant’s suggested lease modifications because they would impair the “financeability” of the property, so the tenant must understand lender concerns. In general, the lender’s primary concern is the assurance of uninterrupted cash flow; anything that might jeopardize cash flow will be carefully scrutinized. Sensitive lease provisions generally include tenant remedies such as rent abatement, offset rights (deducting damages against rent) and lease termination rights.

 Successful negotiation means more than just the rent  As noted above, each step of the commercial lease process and each provision of the lease agreement provides ample opportunity to improve the deal, and conversely, expose the landlord or tenant to costly and unnecessary expense. The successful negotiation will focus on more than just rent. By reducing risks and avoiding surprises, the frantic calls for help may be a thing of the past.

Part 7 – Common lease components

Below is a discussion of several provisions found in a typical lease agreement, and a brief summary of the issues and negotiating positions for each party. These are critical to focus on in every lease transaction as each could ultimately make or break the deal. Please also see the sample tenant checklist available on my webpage for other issues to consider for each lease review.

1. Construction and tenant improvements: Almost every lease provides for the construction or installation of tenant improvements to the leased premises or the surrounding areas for the tenant’s use, ranging from construction of an entire building to moving a wall. There are aspects of this process, including design, approval, timing, and execution of the construction, that are common to all leases, and are often found in the Work Letter attached to the Lease (which is often fully negotiated with the LOI). Each aspect should be dealt with to avoid unpleasant surprises later. The Work Letter can be very specific and must accurately reflect the complete arrangement of work between the parties. Also, the construction contract and related documents (not just the plans and specifications) are often prepared by an architect or other non-lawyer who relies heavily on forms and fails to notice conflicts between the language of the form and the deal as understood by the parties. The lawyer must review the construction provisions and exhibits carefully, as most construction disputes flow from the failure of the parties to have a common understanding, as reflected in a clearly worded document, and all terms and conditions should be reviewed and fully approved by the project manager or other construction personnel before execution of the lease.

 

Part 5 – The Letter of Intent

For purposes of this article, the negotiation process begins with the Letter of Intent (or LOI), which can only be developed after the tenant understands its needs. The LOI represents a compilation of the many considerations that a tenant might have. All of the tenant’s needs and core requirements (both business and legal) should be considered when developing the LOI, as it is difficult to obtain the best result when important considerations are introduced late in the negotiation. Further, the LOI should be consistent with market conditions and what the particular tenant can attain in the current marketplace (i.e. Fortune 500 credit will normally be able to ask for more than a smaller tenant with local credit) and the LOI should be customized to properly reflect the same.

The LOI, once presented, becomes the basis for the negotiation and helps maintain a focus on issues not fully resolved between the parties. Even if non-binding, deviating from terms agreed upon in the LOI is difficult. Accordingly, the importance of initially addressing all significant items in the LOI cannot be overemphasized. For example: (1) the tenant’s negotiating leverage will be reduced if provisions such as options to extend or terminate, liability limitations, escalation and security deposit provisions, rights of first refusal, and other items of significance are not included in the LOI, and (2) it serves everyone’s interests to spend extra time on the details of the LOI to minimize misunderstandings during negotiations, together with the associated cost of attorneys and other professionals engaged by the parties. To preserve that the LOI will not be binding, the document should not only provide as such, but should further provide that it imposes no legal obligation to continue negotiations to reach agreement. Alternatively, the parties may be obligated to negotiate in good faith, and if no formal agreement is reached within a prescribed period of time, either party may terminate negotiations.

As a result, it is important to employ an effective method of tracking the progress made on deal points, while also assuring that the original points eventually are addressed. This has the added benefit of documenting the negotiation, which is useful to understand the intent of the parties and to draft language accurately reflecting all negotiated points.

Rent: Just One Side of a Commercial Lease Agreement

My blogs for the next week or so will contain excerpts from an article I co-wrote for the ACC Docket, November 2010 edition, titled “Rent: Just One Side of a Commercial Lease Agreement.”  The discussion contained in the article was written for corporate lawyers, but applies to a much wider audience as it describes the importance of careful planning and analysis throughout the leasing process, and also emphasizes the need for the tenant to focus on each provision contained in the definitive lease agreement.  A successful lease negotiation focuses on more than just the base rental amount, as vital components of reducing a company’s occupancy costs include mitigating risks and exposure to unforeseen expenses, maximizing flexibility and operating efficiencies, and aligning the company’s real estate strategy with its overall business plan. 

I hope these postings will be enjoyable to read and informative.  Feel free to call or email, and we’ll show you why we’re Studley!

Negotiating the lease deal

It is amazing how often companies find themselves looking for guidance because an unpleasant surprise has come up during the term of their lease, with the vast majority of such issues costing them significant dollars (that wasn’t included in their budgets) in attorneys’ fees and costs to remedy the situation.  Often such surprises are due to having signed a poorly understood or poorly constructed lease agreement and could have easily been avoided.  This is especially true of smaller, less sophisticated tenants who, for whatever reason, sign the landlord’s “Standard Form Lease” with few, if any, changes. 

A lease is much like a partnership agreement in that it governs a business relationship that could last for many years.  When everything goes as planned, most leases will serve the parties well but the true test occurs when there are hiccups in the relationship.  If the lease has not been carefully drafted, a hiccup can become a major problem.  Tenants often lose sight of the fact that the “Standard Form Lease” represents the landlord’s wish list, and if not appropriately modified, will likely not serve their interests when issues arise. 

Most tenant rep firms do not fully protect their clients throughout the entire leasing process, as achieving a favorable deal includes the careful negotiation of the definitive lease agreement.  This is where our Studley team differs from the rest.  We’d be happy to show you why we’re Studley!